I Tried Printful & Printify in 2024 - Do NOT Choose Wrong!!
TLDRIn this video, the creator compares two popular print-on-demand services, Printful and Printify, to help viewers decide which one to choose for their online store. They discuss the importance of selecting a good supplier and how it can impact shipping costs, product quality, and customer satisfaction. The video includes a detailed comparison of the two services, including their order management processes, product catalogs, pricing, shipping times, packaging, and customer service. The creator also shares their personal experiences after ordering samples from both platforms, providing insights into the quality and consistency of the products received. They conclude that while Printify may offer lower prices and a wider variety of products, Printful provides more consistent quality and reliability, making it a safer choice for those who prioritize product quality over cost.
Takeaways
- π **Supplier Choice is Crucial**: Selecting the right supplier for your print-on-demand store can make or break your business due to factors like shipping costs, product quality, and customer retention.
- π **Printful vs Printify Operations**: Printful manages orders in-house, while Printify acts as a middleman connecting you with third-party suppliers, which can affect pricing, quality, and service.
- π‘ **Research and Comparison**: The author conducted a personal comparison by ordering samples, checking software, shipping times, packaging, product quality, pricing, and customer service from both Printful and Printify.
- π **Printify's Pricing Advantage**: Printify often offers lower prices due to competition among its many suppliers, but this can come with trade-offs in quality and service.
- π¨ **Design Interface**: Both platforms offer user-friendly design interfaces, with the ability to upload logos and customize product listings, but the experience may vary slightly between the two.
- π¦ **Packaging and Shipping**: Printful's packaging was environmentally friendly, arriving in a cardboard box without bubble wrap, whereas Printify used a foam cube.
- π **T-shirt Quality**: The Gilden 5000 t-shirts from both Printful and Printify were of similar quality, with slight variations in print saturation and color.
- β **Mug Comparison**: Printify's mug had a lower price point but a noisier print, while Printful's mug was more expensive but offered a higher quality print and faster shipping.
- π§’ **Hat Quality Variance**: The Printful hat had a consistent quality and was well-received, whereas the Printify hat had quality issues, including poor embroidery and an uncentered design.
- π **Supplier Dependence**: The success with Printify can be more variable and supplier-dependent, whereas Printful offers more consistency in product quality and shipping times.
- ποΈ **Recommendation to Test**: The author recommends ordering samples from both Printful and Printify to personally assess product quality, pricing, and service before making a decision.
Q & A
What are the two biggest print on demand suppliers discussed in the transcript?
-The two biggest print on demand suppliers discussed in the transcript are Printful and Printify.
What is the fundamental difference between Printful and Printify in terms of order management?
-The fundamental difference is that Printful manages orders in-house, making, packaging, and shipping the products themselves, while Printify acts as a middleman, contracting out the printing, shipping, and fulfillment to third-party suppliers.
What factors can affect the quality and cost of products from print on demand services?
-Factors that can affect the quality and cost include the supplier's production speed, quality of print, stock reliability, location for shipping times, and whether the supplier offers express delivery.
How does the number of products sold affect the pricing on Printful?
-On Printful, the more products you sell, the lower the price per product becomes due to their bulk pricing calculator. Additionally, joining a membership can also save you money.
What is the advantage of ordering samples from Printful?
-Ordering samples from Printful allows you to test the product quality, and Printful offers discounted prices for samples, which can be a good way to evaluate the product before committing to larger orders.
What is the significance of the supplier's location in relation to shipping times?
-The supplier's location is significant because it affects how quickly the product can be shipped to the customer. A supplier located closer to the customer or with express delivery options will generally result in faster shipping times.
What is the difference in the product catalog between Printful and Printify?
-Printify has a larger product catalog due to its use of multiple third-party suppliers, offering a wider variety of products, while Printful has a more limited catalog but handles all aspects of production in-house.
How does Printify's system of rating suppliers impact the customer's choice?
-Printify's rating system, based on production speed, quality, and stock reliability, helps customers choose suppliers that meet their needs for quality and delivery time, although higher-rated suppliers may come with higher prices.
What are the environmental considerations when choosing between Printful and Printify based on the packaging described?
-Printful's packaging is more environmentally friendly as it uses a cardboard box that folds into itself without the need for bubble wrap or Styrofoam, whereas Printify's packaging uses a foam cube.
What is the narrator's recommendation for someone who is unsure about choosing between Printful and Printify?
-The narrator recommends testing out both services by ordering samples from each to get a feel for the product quality, shipping times, and pricing before making a decision.
What is the narrator's conclusion about the quality and reliability of Printful and Printify?
-The narrator concludes that Printful is a safer bet due to its consistent quality and reliability, while Printify can be cheaper and faster but may involve more of a gamble due to the variability in supplier quality.
Outlines
π§ Introduction to Print on Demand Services
The speaker begins by expressing their intent to explore and compare two prominent print on demand services, Printful and Printify, to determine which is superior. They emphasize the importance of selecting a good supplier for a successful online store and mention the potential drawbacks of a bad supplier. The speaker outlines their plan to order samples, review the software, shipping times, packaging, product quality, pricing, and customer service from both platforms. They also clarify the fundamental differences between Printful and Printify, noting that Printful handles all processes in-house, while Printify acts as a middleman connecting users with third-party suppliers.
π Comparing Product Catalogs and Pricing
The speaker discusses the process of setting up accounts with both Printful and Printify and delves into the differences in their product catalogs. They highlight the greater variety of products available on Printify due to its use of multiple suppliers. The speaker also compares the pricing of a specific t-shirt model, the Gildan 5000, on both platforms, noting that while Printify often offers lower prices, the quality of service and product can vary. They mention the ability to filter suppliers on Printify based on production speed, quality, stock reliability, and express delivery options.
π¨ Design Interface and Customization
The speaker provides a walkthrough of the design interfaces for both Printful and Printify, demonstrating how to upload logos and customize product placement. They mention the various printing options available on Printful, such as different placements on the t-shirt. The speaker also discusses the ease of use and the mockup views provided by both platforms, allowing users to visualize how their designs will appear on the products.
ποΈ Ordering Samples and Shipping
The speaker describes the process of ordering sample products from both Printful and Printify, including the selection of suppliers, customization of designs, and the calculation of shipping costs. They note the differences in shipping times and costs, with Printful offering a discount for sample orders and potentially saving on shipping by consolidating orders from different suppliers. The speaker also mentions their decision to order additional products, such as a mug and a hat, to further compare the services.
π¦ Arrival and Unboxing of Products
The speaker shares their experience upon receiving the ordered products from Printful and Printify. They unbox and evaluate each item, comparing the quality, print accuracy, and packaging. The speaker notes the reasonable shipping times and acceptable quality of the Printful hat, while expressing disappointment with the Printify hat's poor embroidery quality and material. They also compare t-shirts from both services, noting the similarity in appearance and quality, and discuss the mugs, highlighting the packaging and environmental impact.
π Conclusion and Recommendations
The speaker concludes by summarizing their findings from the comparison between Printful and Printify. They note that while Printful provided consistent quality and reliable service, Printify offered a mix of good and not-so-good experiences depending on the supplier. The speaker advises viewers to test both services by ordering samples to determine which one best suits their needs. They suggest Printful as a safe bet for reliability and quality, but acknowledge that Printify can sometimes offer better pricing and faster shipping.
Mindmap
Keywords
Print on Demand
Supplier
Printify
Printful
Product Quality
Shipping Costs
Customer Service
Pricing
Design Interface
Sample Orders
Environmental Impact
Highlights
The author compared Printful and Printify, two leading print-on-demand services, to determine which is superior for setting up a successful online store.
Choosing the right supplier is crucial for the success of an online store, as it can impact shipping costs, product quality, and customer satisfaction.
Printful operates in-house, managing the entire process from production to shipping, while Printify acts as a middleman connecting customers with third-party suppliers.
Printify often offers lower prices due to competition among its many suppliers, but Printful might provide better quality and customer service.
The author ordered samples from both services to compare product quality, shipping times, packaging, pricing, and customer service.
Printify has a larger product catalog and allows customers to choose from different suppliers based on ratings for production speed, quality, and stock reliability.
Printful offers bulk pricing and membership options that can reduce costs as the number of products sold increases.
The design interfaces for both Printful and Printify are user-friendly, allowing for easy customization and product mockup views.
Shipping costs can vary significantly between the two services, with potential savings when ordering multiple products that ship from the same supplier.
The author found that not all products are cheaper on Printify, and the quality of the final product can depend on the specific supplier chosen.
Printful's product packaging was more environmentally friendly, using a cardboard box that does not require bubble wrap.
The Printful hat had a better print quality and material compared to the Printify hat, which appeared dirty and had a poor print job.
Both Printful and Printify t-shirts had similar quality, with slight variations in print saturation and color.
The Printify mug, despite its lower price, had a grainy print, while the Printful mug offered a richer color and better print accuracy at a higher price.
The author concludes that Printful is a safer bet for consistent quality and reliability, while Printify can be a gamble but may offer faster shipping or lower prices.
It is recommended to test both services by ordering samples to determine which one best fits the needs and quality standards of your online store.